We’re Baking Bay Sweeter

Baking custom sweet treats with a personal touch, for our friends and neighbors, and you!

Introducing…

We specialize in custom sugar cookies and monthly cookie drops. Made out of our home kitchen in Bay Village with only the best ingredients for you and your loved ones!

Decorated cookies with New York City skyline, coffee, and holiday motifs.

Custom Themed Sugar Cookies

Starting at* $75 / dozen

Decorated cookies with white icing and black handwritten text that reads "a sweet thank you" with a heart symbol, placed on a wire cooling rack.

Custom Edible Printed Cookies

Starting at* $50 / dozen

Who we are

We’re home bakers with a passion for creating wonderful custom treats that will make your event or special day truly complete. More than that, though, we’re a family business; we bake in our own kitchen.

Founded in 2020, we bring the tools, techniques, and creativity to make all the cookies, all the time. From custom, hand-decorated designs that are perfectly on-theme (and on schedule) to thousands of edible printed logos, we’re proud to be your local bakers making every occasion a little sweeter.